Re: Glimpse of the Past
Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2022 12:23 pm
Yes, precisely. Sometimes negative feedback can be good and constructive. It has definitely helped inspire me to develop some characters to be more sympathetic (including some of the characters who were initially cold villains, like Toshiko or Meredith & Lucinda).rufusluciusivan wrote: Tue Nov 15, 2022 8:17 amWell, I'm not saying it's always a bad thing. Personally, I can recall several occasions when I modified things after I received a negative feedback (such as Catalina's character - which in hindsight allowed me to imagine one of my favorite group dynamidc in my stories, a democratic team of uniform stealers- in hindsight I regret not having used them more). And had I the time or the motivation to rewrite some parts of Pakal, I'd know exactly what I'd want to do to improve Tsuki's character arc.
Yes, certainly a lot of it is subjective, but that's part of what makes the different reactions interesting. Especially since there are certain baseline storytelling concepts which everyone here can agree on finding objectively entertaining (specifically, the mugging of women for their clothesI guess it's actually sometimes easier to be the one who receives the feedback rather than the one who gives it...I mean, we're not professional writers or critics, we're between people who share, in-between friends so to speak. The point of our comments are first and foremost to share our passion, and to encourage each other. So I sometimes feel awkward when I criticize the work of someone who did something for free on their free time... Especially when it comes to characters' personalities, since it's often very subjective.

I have the exact reaction with writing these stories. Once I start a new chapter, it becomes easier to continue, but it can be difficult to work up the motivation. I have a few chapters outlined, it's all a matter of finding the time and motivation. But once I start, hopefully it can get back on track.I usually share your opinion about reading stories as they're hot off the press, but lately I seem to have some sort of blocking. I guess I need to give myself a kick in the backside, so to speak.
Usually, starting to read is the hardest part - once I have started, it's easier. I'll try to grab a bit of time during that couple of weeks.
